Where did this narrative of "screwing up", "screwing his team", etc. come from? The events, as we know them:
Early 2018:
- SE management approves a 2nd round of FFXV DLC for 2019
- BD2 is reorganized into Luminous Productions, with a focus on next gen. Tabata is appointed as the studio head.
Fast forward a few months:
- SE management decides to change the charter or direction of the studio. Tabata obviously disagrees.
- SE and Tabata try and work out a path forward. But it doesn't work out, so Tabata leaves.
- As a result, SE cancels 3 of the 4 planned FFXV DLC and writes down ~$33M USD. What the charge actually entails, we don't know.
In the tech industry, this chain of events is....very normal. There's no "fault" to be had. And rarely does it have anything to do with competence, performance, or whatever adjective gamers want to attach. (I'd argue that since SE and Tabata tried to work something out it speaks to how highly they regarded him.) It's simply shifting business priorities.
Tabata will be fine. The only leverage he had with SE was his continued employment. He led a team to deliver a highly-regarded (and my favorite) FF game to impressive sales on multiple platforms.
The rest of the team will be fine. These are highly competent professionals. For those who think Tabata was "indispensable," drive past a graveyard sometime. It took a team effort to rescue the project and the FF brand name.
And why are we talking about Nomura? How does he factor into this at all?
TL;DR - It's just business.
Unfortunately, the fans are the ones who are screwed. We're not getting the promised DLC and PC utilities (mod tools, etc.) - very disappointing. But I'll choose to look on the bright side. I got almost 2 years of additional content for my favorite FF game. It's been a fun ride, but it's time to say goodbye to Noctis and friends.