Fans want a showing of fresh material, not a showing of old stuff they've already seen before. If you're not going to show anything new, then it's going to be treated as a no show.
The FFXV TGS 2013 showing is not much different then Versus XIII not showing up at a gaming convention. The fan reaction was the same.
Yes, I agree with this, but why wouldn't they show anything new? It's been an entire year (or will be by E3 time), why WOULDN'T they have anything new to show? Yes, the fan reaction WOULD be the same, but that's implying they wouldn't have anything to show... I don't get why this is your default response to this, as if it's the only option. I'll say it again, it will have been an entire year by that point... they definitely have things to show.
And who really believes this?
Well, considering the amount of small bits of information we've gotten about the game, I certainly do. Why wouldn't I believe them, am I supposed to have it out for Square Enix or something?
If the game doesn’t show up at E3, the reaction will be like it has always been to the people who have been waiting for this game since E3 2006. The damage has already been done. It can’t get any worse. It's just going to be the same damn thing.
Those who have been waiting since the Versus days don't care if it has been rebranded. It's not going to change the fact that they've been waiting almost 8 years now for this game. It's not a new beginning. Nothing has changed just because it's a numbered title now. Last I checked, Versus and FFXV are still the same thing.
If the game doesn't show up at E3, the reaction will be fans wondering where the game is, considering the progress was stated to be "quite far into development", I'll quote the Nova Crystallis article for this one:
Instead Hashimoto offered up a bit of an explanation, saying he realizes fans have been waiting a long time, and the development team is working hard to meet what now must be astronomical expectations for a game nearing 10 years in the making. While he stressed that they would like to publish new information “soon,” in truth no timeline was given and instead fans must continue to “wait a little longer."
Again, I don't know what you mean by damage... you still haven't clarified what you mean by damage... Damage to the brand? Damage to Square Enix? Damage to the game?
To the fans of Versus XIII, XV WAS a bit of something new, it was the rebirth of the game they hadn't heard from in a long time; it was the moment they were waiting for to further instil hope in the game they've been patiently waiting for on the next generation consoles. Nothing has changed drastically, sure... but what meaning does this have? I don't really understand the purpose of this paragraph, and what you were trying to say with it.
My point is, fans will be disappointed if it's not at E3 this year, you say that it's more of the same we've seen... but you're forgetting that we were explained WHY we didn't hear anything about the game already... and that all of those things behind us now, we won't have the same thing happen again. If Square Enix does the same thing again, they won't have an excuse to fall back on. That is what I've been trying to say this whole time. Before there was no reason or excuse, just no information... it was explained why there was a blackout of information, and now we should expect to see information... and so if we don't, then we can't trust Square Enix's word.